For most of the 20th century, Chicagoans proudly declared their city had the largest Polish population in the world outside of Warsaw. Politicians repeated it. Tour guides proclaimed it. It became part of the city's identity. There's just one problem: it was always a bit of statistical gymnastics, and it's definitely not true anymore.

The claim hinged on comparing apples to oranges. When people said "Chicago," they usually meant the entire Chicago metropolitan area—a sprawling region that includes dozens of suburbs. Warsaw's number, meanwhile, referred only to the city proper. It's like saying your high school has more students than Harvard by counting everyone in your entire school district.

The Numbers Don't Add Up

Today, Warsaw's city population sits at approximately 1.8 million people, nearly all of Polish ethnicity. Chicago's city limits contain about 210,000 people of Polish ancestry—roughly 7.3% of the city's population. Even if you count the entire Chicago metropolitan area, you're looking at around 800,000 Polish Americans, still less than Warsaw proper.

And here's the kicker: London overtook Chicago around 2012. Following Poland's entry into the European Union, hundreds of thousands of Polish workers moved to the UK. London now hosts one of the world's largest Polish populations outside Poland, with approximately 700,000 Polish-born residents across the United Kingdom.

Why the Myth Persists

The legend isn't entirely baseless. During the late 19th and early 20th centuries, massive waves of Polish immigrants did transform Chicago. Neighborhoods like Avondale, Jefferson Park, and Archer Heights became distinctly Polish enclaves. At its peak in the 1930s, some estimates suggested over 400,000 Polish immigrants and their children lived in Chicago—a genuinely staggering number for the era.

The city's Polish community left an indelible mark:

Polish was the second most common language in Chicago schools for decades
The city became home to more Polish newspapers than any city outside Poland
Iconic institutions like the Polish Museum of America preserve this heritage
You can still find authentic Polish restaurants, bakeries, and cultural centers throughout the metro area

Other Polish Powerhouses

Chicago isn't alone in its Polish pride. Cities around the world host substantial Polish communities. Curitiba, Brazil has about 400,000 residents of Polish descent. Toronto claims around 200,000. New York City actually has slightly more people of Polish ancestry than Chicago proper—about 213,000—though it represents a smaller percentage of the city's massive population.

So while Chicago's claim to be the "second-largest Polish city" doesn't hold water anymore, the city's Polish-American legacy remains very real. You just have to be more careful about how you phrase it at your next trivia night.

Related Tags