In 1989, astronomer Alan Lightman from MIT and researcher Jon D. Miller conducted a telephone survey that would reveal a startling truth about American science literacy. When 1,111 adults across the country were asked whether the sun is a star, only 55% answered correctly. Nearly half the nation didn't know that the blazing ball of light in our sky is the same type of object as those twinkling dots we see at night.

The survey, published in Social Studies of Science, sent shockwaves through the scientific community. How could such a fundamental astronomical fact be unknown to 45% of Americans?

Why This Matters More Than You'd Think

At first glance, not knowing the sun is a star might seem like harmless trivia. But this knowledge gap reveals something deeper about how we understand our place in the universe. The sun isn't special because it's different from stars—it's special because it's our star, close enough to warm our planet and make life possible.

The other stars we see at night are distant suns, many with their own planets orbiting them. Understanding this connection is fundamental to grasping concepts like:

How stars work and why they shine
The true scale of the universe
The possibility of life on other planets
Why seasons happen and how orbits function

The Education Gap

The 1989 results highlighted a significant failure in science education. The sun being a star isn't advanced astrophysics—it's typically taught in elementary school. Yet somehow, this basic fact wasn't sticking with nearly half the adult population.

Researchers pointed to several culprits: inadequate science curricula, poor teacher training in STEM subjects, and the human tendency to see the sun as fundamentally different from nighttime stars because of how differently they appear to us.

Have Things Improved?

The good news: science literacy in America has gradually improved since 1989. The National Science Foundation continues to track public understanding of science, and more recent surveys show progress on various fronts.

The complicated news: significant gaps remain. A 2014 NSF survey found that only 74% of Americans knew the Earth revolves around the sun—meaning one in four adults still get this wrong. While that's better than the 1989 results for star knowledge, it shows we still have work to do on basic astronomy.

Modern surveys tend to ask different questions than they did in 1989, making direct comparisons tricky. The "Is the sun a star?" question appears less frequently in contemporary research, possibly because it's considered too basic—or perhaps because researchers don't want to face those depressing numbers again.

The Bright Side

Before we despair entirely, context matters. Americans actually perform comparably to—or better than—citizens of other developed nations on similar science literacy tests. A European Union survey found only 66% of EU residents correctly answered that the Earth orbits the sun.

Researchers who study scientific literacy also note that knowing facts isn't the same as understanding science. Someone might flub a trivia question but still grasp scientific reasoning and methodology. That said, knowing the sun is a star seems like a pretty reasonable bar to clear.

The 1989 survey became a wake-up call for science educators, spurring reforms and increased emphasis on astronomy in schools. While we haven't achieved perfect science literacy, that 55% figure helped us recognize how much work needed to be done—and still needs doing today.

Related Tags