📅This fact may be outdated

Major manufacturers stopped using thorium around 1990, switching to non-radioactive alternatives like yttrium. While some thorium mantles are still manufactured (primarily in China), they're no longer the standard. The nuclear reactor alarm claim appears to be folklore - I found one 1980 incident where a mantle triggered a health physicist's scintillation counter during a nuclear plant tour, but no documented cases of setting off actual reactor alarms.

The little bags of netting for gas lanterns (called 'mantles') are radioactive...so much so that they will set of an alarm at a nuclear reactor.

Gas Lantern Mantles Were Radioactive Enough to Glow (Literally)

1k viewsPosted 16 years agoUpdated 3 hours ago

If you went camping before 1990, there's a good chance you carried radioactive material in your gear. Those delicate mesh bags that make gas lanterns glow - called mantles - contained thorium dioxide, a mildly radioactive element that could actually register on radiation detection equipment.

In October 1980, a health physicist named Walter Wagner toured California's Rancho Seco nuclear power plant with a scintillation counter. When he held it near a Coleman lantern mantle he'd brought along, the device registered a measurable radiation signature. It wasn't enough to trigger facility alarms, but it proved these innocent-looking camping supplies were genuinely radioactive.

Why Put Radioactive Material in Camping Gear?

Thorium wasn't added to mantles by accident - it was the secret to their incredible brightness. When heated by burning gas, thorium dioxide becomes incandescent, producing a brilliant white light far superior to the flame alone. A typical mantle contained about 250mg of thorium (0.027 microcuries), though some contained up to 400mg.

The dose rates weren't apocalyptic. A single mantle measured 0.68 microsieverts per hour on its surface. An avid camper using a lantern every other weekend for a year would receive 3-6 microsieverts of radiation - tiny compared to the 2,400 microsieverts you absorb annually from natural background radiation.

The Radioactive Boy Scout Connection

The radioactivity became more concerning when concentrated. In 1994, 17-year-old David Hahn built a model breeder reactor in his mother's potting shed using materials including thorium ash from thousands of lantern mantles. Even after dismantling his creation, local radiation levels measured 1,000 times background levels.

Hahn had exploited a loophole: you could legally buy radioactive material by the mantle, and nobody tracked bulk purchases. His experiment drew national attention and highlighted the surprising accessibility of radioactive consumer products.

What Happened to Thorium Mantles?

Around 1990, major manufacturers like Coleman quietly switched from thorium to yttrium, a non-radioactive alternative that produces similar incandescence. The change was driven by public awareness rather than health concerns - the actual radiation exposure from normal use was negligible.

However, thorium mantles didn't disappear completely. Chinese manufacturers still produce them, though quality varies wildly. According to Coleman collectors who test mantles with radiation meters, some Chinese mantles are "hot" while others barely register above background levels. Without a Geiger counter, there's no way to know which type you're buying.

So while modern camping mantles are generally safe, vintage ones from the thorium era remain mildly radioactive. If you've got old camping gear in the garage, you might be storing a piece of radioactive history.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are camping lantern mantles still radioactive?
Most modern mantles are not radioactive. Major manufacturers like Coleman switched from thorium to non-radioactive yttrium around 1990, though some Chinese-made thorium mantles are still available.
How much radiation do thorium lantern mantles emit?
A typical thorium mantle emits about 0.68 microsieverts per hour on its surface. Annual exposure from regular camping use (3-6 microsieverts) is tiny compared to natural background radiation (2,400 microsieverts per year).
Why did gas lanterns contain radioactive thorium?
Thorium dioxide becomes incandescent when heated, producing brilliant white light. It made mantles far brighter than the gas flame alone, which is why it was used despite being radioactive.
Can you still buy radioactive lantern mantles?
Some Chinese manufacturers still produce thorium mantles, but quality and thorium content vary. Without a radiation meter, there's no way to tell if a mantle contains thorium.
Is it safe to use vintage lantern mantles with thorium?
Normal use poses minimal health risk since thorium emits mostly alpha particles that can't penetrate skin. However, you should avoid carrying mantles in pockets or inhaling dust from burnt mantles.

Related Topics

More from Science & Space