In a country that prides itself on being number one, there's a delicious irony hiding in plain sight on virtually every street corner: Second Street is America's most common street name, while First Street languishes down in sixth place.

How did second place become first? The answer lies in American urban planning quirks that have been confusing visitors and delighting trivia enthusiasts for over a century.

The Main Street Problem

When American towns were founded, settlers didn't typically start numbering from "First Street." Instead, the central thoroughfare—the one with all the shops, the bank, and the town hall—got a proper name: Main Street.

This meant that numbered streets often began with Second Street, running parallel to Main. First Street? It either didn't exist or got pushed to the edge of town where nobody cared about it.

What Knocked First Street Down?

According to the U.S. Census Bureau's analysis of street names, the top ten most common are:

Second Street (first place, ironically)
Third Street
First Street... wait, no
Fourth Street
Park Street
Fifth Street
First Street (finally showing up in sixth)
Main Street
Sixth Street
Oak Street

First Street didn't just lose to Second—it got beaten by Third, Fourth, and Fifth Streets too. Park Street even sneaked past it.

The Geography of Naming

Different regions have their own naming conventions that further complicate things. In the South, you're more likely to find streets named after trees—Magnolia, Peachtree, or Oak. In New England, historical figures dominate. Out West, numbered streets are more common, but the "Main Street takes First's spot" rule still applies.

Some cities tried to be clever. Washington, D.C. has no First Street near the Capitol because the National Mall takes that space. In Manhattan, the numbered streets start at Houston (pronounced "HOW-stun," not like the Texas city), so there's no First through Eighth Street at all in most of the island.

The Practical Nightmare

Having thousands of Second Streets across America creates genuine chaos. GPS systems struggle. Emergency services have documented cases of ambulances going to the wrong Second Street in the wrong town. The U.S. Postal Service processes millions of pieces of misdelivered mail annually, with common street names being a major culprit.

Some municipalities have started requiring unique street names within certain radiuses, but Second Street's dominance was established long before anyone thought about such regulations.

A Monument to American Practicality

There's something beautifully American about this whole situation. Towns needed a main commercial street, so they called it Main Street. They needed parallel streets for residential areas, so they numbered them—starting with Two, because One was already taken by a street with a "better" name.

Nobody planned for Second Street to become the most common street name in the nation. It just happened, one town at a time, through pure practical logic repeated thousands of times over.

So next time you're standing on Second Street—and statistically, you will be eventually—take a moment to appreciate this accidental monument to American urban planning. In a nation obsessed with being first, second place quietly won.

Related Tags