Alec Guinness Called Star Wars "Fairy-Tale Rubbish." It Made Him $95 Million.

Alec Guinness thought so little of Star Wars that he called it "fairy-tale rubbish" and complained "none of the dialogue makes my character clear or even bearable." He negotiated 2.25% of the gross revenue. His roughly 20 minutes of screen time in the original film earned him an estimated $95 million over his lifetime. His estate is believed to still collect royalties.

Alec Guinness Called Star Wars "Fairy-Tale Rubbish." It Made Him $95 Million.

Posted 10 hours agoUpdated 1 hour ago

In December 1975, Alec Guinness was one of the most respected actors in British cinema. He had an Oscar, a knighthood, and decades of acclaimed performances. Then he read the script for a science fiction film being directed by a young American named George Lucas.

"Fairy-tale rubbish," he wrote in a letter to his friend Anne Kaufman, "but could be interesting perhaps."

In a follow-up letter from March 1976, during filming, he was less charitable: "None of the dialogue makes my character clear or even bearable."

The Deal

Guinness negotiated a percentage of the gross revenue rather than a larger flat fee: 2% initially. George Lucas, impressed with Guinness's contribution, personally called him before the film's San Francisco premiere and offered an additional half percent. Through what appears to have been a miscommunication by a producer, the extra amount was documented as 0.25% rather than the 0.5% Lucas intended. Being English and unwilling to make a fuss, Guinness accepted. His final deal was 2.25% of the gross.

It was, by any measure, the best deal of his career.

$95 Million for 20 Minutes

Guinness's screen time as Obi-Wan Kenobi in the original Star Wars amounts to roughly 20 minutes. The film grossed $775 million worldwide. The sequels added more. The re-releases, home video sales, and streaming deals compounded the revenue for decades.

By the time Guinness died on August 5, 2000, his Star Wars royalties had earned him an estimated $95 million. The "fairy-tale rubbish" he had been so skeptical of paid him more than every other role in his career combined.

His estate is believed to continue collecting royalties. The fairy tale goes on.

Frequently Asked Questions

Did Alec Guinness really call Star Wars fairy-tale rubbish?
Yes. The exact phrase appears in a December 1975 letter to his friend Anne Kaufman. The full quote was fairy-tale rubbish but could be interesting perhaps.
How much did Guinness earn from Star Wars?
An estimated $95 million over his lifetime from his 2.25% gross revenue deal. This is from roughly 20 minutes of screen time in the original film.
What was Guinness''s deal?
He negotiated 2% of gross revenue. George Lucas later added 0.25% (intending 0.5%, but a producer miscommunicated the figure). The total was 2.25%.
Does the Guinness estate still earn from Star Wars?
It is widely believed so, given the perpetual nature of his gross revenue deal, though specific current figures are not publicly disclosed.

Verified Fact

Verified via Time, Gizmodo (Letters Live), Celebrity Net Worth, Hollywood Reporter, Looper, Fandomwire. "Fairy-tale rubbish" from Dec 22 1975 letter to Anne Kaufman -- full quote includes "but could be interesting perhaps." Dialogue quote from March 1976 letter. 2.25% deal confirmed (2% + 0.25%). Screen time ~20 min (not 12). Key correction from original research: his diary shows he HOPED for Jaws-level success, not that he expected it to bomb. Reframed to focus on his disdain for the material rather than false "expected flop" narrative.

Looper

More from Entertainment